Moving to Vancouver Island, a list of pros and cons (2024)

Have you been thinking about moving to Vancouver Island? I’ve got you covered!

This year, I made the leap, moving to this breathtaking corner of the world, and I’ve had the pleasure of living in both Nanaimo and Victoria—each offering its unique blend of island charm and vibrant city life.

From the tranquil shores of Nanaimo to the bustling streets of Victoria, I’ve navigated the ins and outs of settling on this beautiful island. I understand the mix of excitement and uncertainty that comes with moving to a new place, especially from abroad!

Through my journey, I’ve gathered insights, tips, and a whole lot of stories to share with you. Whether you’re curious about the cost of living, the best neighbourhoods, or simply what to expect from island weather (hint: keep an umbrella handy), I’m here to offer a firsthand perspective.

As someone who’s walked the path you’re considering, my goal is to help make your transition as smooth as possible. I love living here but so you can make a decision for yourself, let’s dive into some of the pros and cons of moving to Vancouver Island.

2. Access to nature

On Vancouver Island, the way nature seamlessly integrates with daily life continuously blows my mind and it is one of my favourite things about the island. There is so much nature everywhere you look that you don’t have to travel far to be immersed in it.

This accessibility means that even within the island’s cities, from the bustling streets of Victoria to the quieter, laid-back vibe of smaller towns like Courtenay, the presence of nature is everywhere all while maintaining a raw feel.

The easy access to vast wilderness areas, combined with the convenience of city amenities, ensures that residents can enjoy the best of both worlds. Whether it’s hiking a coastal trail in the morning or enjoying a bite to eat at a cafe in the afternoon, life here is all about balance.

3. Mild climate

Vancouver Island has a really mild climate that’s pretty easy to love, especially if you’re not a fan of extreme weather. The winters are cool but not too cold, and you won’t see much snow – except if you arrive in the middle of a polar blast like we did! Summers are warm enough for enjoying the outdoors but not too hot.

The mild temperatures not only ensure that outdoor activities are possible year-round but also significantly contribute to the quality of life here. Unlike the harsh winters seen in many parts of Canada, the island’s winter season sees more rain than snowfall and freezing temperatures.

It’s perfect for anyone who wants to keep active and be close to nature without dealing with harsh winters. Plus, this nice weather helps make everything look green and beautiful, adding to the island’s charm.

4. Incredible wildlife

One of the coolest things is the incredible wildlife on Vancouver Island. It’s like living in a nature documentary! You might see eagles flying overhead (quite literally! Just the other week two bald eagles flew past my window while I was working from home), cute deer wandering through neighbourhoods, or even orcas splashing around in the sea.

The island is home to all sorts of animals, big and small, and it’s pretty amazing to see them in their natural habitat. Whether you’re going for a walk in the forest or just hanging out by the water, you never know what friendly critter you might run into next.

I’ve spotted seals numerous times while out for a walk near the ocean! It’s all part of the adventure of living here, making every day a little more exciting.

5. Cultural and artistic events

Vancouver Island is buzzing with cultural and artistic events that bring colour and creativity to the community. Throughout the year, you can catch music festivals, art shows, and theatre productions that showcase local and international talent.

Places like Victoria light up with events like the Fringe Festival and Jazz Fest, drawing crowds from all over. Smaller towns also have their own unique gatherings, from outdoor concerts to art walks, where you can enjoy the cool island vibe and meet local artists.

Don’t miss the Sidney Fine Art Show, showcasing stunning works from regional artists. Meanwhile, Tofino’s Pacific Rim Whale Festival celebrates the return of the Grey Whales to the West Coast in a week-long festival.

6. Laidback lifestyle

Living on Vancouver Island comes with a laidback lifestyle that’s all about taking it easy and enjoying life’s simple pleasures. Here, the pace slows down, allowing you to savour each moment, whether it’s coffee at a local cafe, a leisurely bike ride through the scenic trails, or a quiet afternoon fishing by the lake.

People value their time, spending it on activities that bring them joy and relaxation rather than rushing through their days. This relaxed approach extends to the workplace too, with a focus on work-life balance.

It’s a place where you can truly unwind, recharge, and connect with what matters most to you. The laidback vibe of the island encourages a healthy lifestyle, fosters strong community bonds, and offers a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life.

I thoroughly enjoy the pace of life here, it’s not too slow and it’s not too fast – if I had to sum it up in one word I’d say it simply feels wholesome.

The cons of moving to Vancouver Island

1. Transport and accessibility

One of the challenges of living on Vancouver Island is the transport and accessibility aspect. Getting around the island itself can be straightforward, especially if you have a car, but if you’re relying on public transport, options can be limited, especially in more rural or remote areas.

This can make it tricky for those without vehicles to access some of the island’s incredible natural spots or even just navigate daily errands efficiently. Additionally, travelling to and from the mainland requires a ferry ride, which, while scenic, adds extra time and planning to any trip. In the summer, since the island is getting more and more popular, the demand for ferries to the island shoots up and securing these becomes more difficult.

This may or may not be a con depending on how to plan to live on the island. Since we first arrived we actually haven’t travelled to the mainland at all. Not because we haven’t wanted to but because we haven’t really had a reason to, everything we need we can find on the island!

Ferry rides back and forward can also become quite costly, especially if you’re commuting regularly or planning frequent visits to the mainland. For those used to the convenience of extensive public transport networks in larger cities, this aspect of island life might require some adjustments.

2. Cost of living

While Vancouver Island offers a picturesque lifestyle, it’s important to note that the cost of living can be a significant consideration for many. Particularly in desirable cities like Victoria, house prices have risen, reflecting the demand for island life.

Rent and real estate aren’t the only things that might stretch your budget; day-to-day expenses such as groceries, utilities, and even dining out can also be higher than in many parts of mainland British Columbia. This is partly due to the logistics and costs associated with transporting goods to the island.

While some areas of the island might offer more affordable living options, these often come with the trade-off of being more remote, potentially increasing transportation and accessibility issues.

3. Limited job market

The job market on Vancouver Island can present challenges, particularly for newcomers looking for employment in specific industries. While there are opportunities, especially in sectors like tourism, hospitality, and government in cities such as Victoria, the range of available positions may not be as broad as in larger urban centres on the mainland.

This limitation is more obvious in specialised fields or high-tech industries, which are more concentrated in bigger cities like Vancouver. Additionally, the island’s more remote locations offer fewer employment opportunities, making it essential for job seekers to be flexible or consider remote working arrangements.

For young professionals or those in niche sectors, this could mean a more extended job search or the need to adapt career plans.

4. Seasonal tourism

Seasonal tourism significantly shapes life on Vancouver Island, especially during the summer months when the population grows with visitors drawn to its natural beauty. Iconic destinations like Tofino, Victoria, and the Gulf Islands become hubs of activity, from crowded beaches to busy restaurants and fully booked accommodation.

While this influx brings a vibrant energy and boosts the local economy, it can also mean increased traffic, longer waits for services and higher prices for both locals and tourists alike. For residents, this seasonal change requires some adjustment, as the quiet, laidback pace of island life gives way to a more hectic tempo.

Planning ahead becomes crucial, whether it’s for a dinner reservation or a weekend getaway. The contrast between the busy tourist season and the more tranquil off-season highlights the island’s dual nature, offering a dynamic living experience that shifts with the seasons.

Cities of Vancouver Island

To understand where you want to live on Vancouver Island, you’ll need to do a bit of research on the different cities as they vary quite a bit from one another. I’ve lived in Nanaimo and Victoria and both cities have been completely different so it really depends on the kind of lifestyle you’re after.

Here’s an overview of some of the main cities and towns:

• Victoria: The capital city of British Columbia, Victoria is known for its historic architecture, vibrant arts scene, and stunning waterfront. Its British colonial past is clear in sites like the Parliament Buildings and the iconic Fairmont Empress Hotel. The city boasts a lively culinary scene, lush gardens, and a variety of cultural festivals throughout the year.
  
• Nanaimo: Often referred to as the Harbour City, Nanaimo is a gateway to the island’s adventures. It offers a blend of urban conveniences and natural beauty, with activities ranging from exploring the waterfront and nearby islands to indulging in the famous Nanaimo bar. Its central location makes it an ideal base for exploring the rest of the island.
  
• Courtenay: Situated in the Comox Valley, Courtenay is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, offering easy access to skiing, hiking, and watersports. The city is also known for its fossil hunting at the nearby Puntledge River and a lively arts and cultural scene.
  
• Campbell River: Dubbed the Salmon Capital of the World, Campbell River is a hotspot for fishing, wildlife viewing, and outdoor recreation. It serves as a starting point for adventures into the island’s more remote northern regions and the Discovery Islands.
  
• Port Alberni: Nestled in a valley on the way to the West Coast, Port Alberni is a hub for accessing the raw beauty of the Pacific Rim. From fishing and boating on the Alberni Inlet to exploring ancient forests, it offers a rustic charm and a slower pace of life.
  
• Tofino: On the island’s west coast, Tofino is renowned for its breathtaking landscapes, surfing beaches, and storm watching. It’s a place where the Pacific Ocean meets ancient rainforests, creating a sanctuary for nature lovers and adventure seekers. It is very small however and gets extremely popular in the summer so while it’s great to visit, it may not be the best choice to live.
  
• Duncan: Known as the City of Totems, Duncan is rich in Indigenous culture, with over 40 totem poles scattered throughout the town. It’s the heart of the Cowichan Valley, a region celebrated for its vineyards, artisanal food producers, and warm climate.

Moving to Vancouver Island tips and checklist

For those considering a move to Vancouver Island, having a practical checklist and some insider tips can make the transition smoother and more enjoyable. Here’s a curated list to guide future islanders!

1. Research Your Ideal Location:
   • Consider factors like climate variations, job opportunities, and lifestyle preferences. Each city and town offers a unique living experience.
     
2. Understand the Cost of Living:
   • Compare housing, groceries, and transportation costs in different areas to budget effectively.
     
3. Plan for Transportation:
   • If you’re bringing a car, check ferry schedules and costs. Consider the accessibility of public transportation and the feasibility of biking or walking in your chosen community. We bought a car after we arrived on the island and the process was pretty easy.
     
4. Secure Housing:
   • Research the housing market early so you know what to expect and can roughly budget for it. Consider short-term rentals while you explore neighbourhoods to find the right fit for a longer-term home. We found Facebook Marketplace was the best for securing sublets.
     
5. Job Hunting:
   • Start your job search ahead of the move, Indeed is really big for job postings in Canada, more so than LinkedIn. Connect with local employment agencies or consider remote work options. I work remotely for a company based in Ontario so that works really well and my boyfriend has a job with a local company.
     
6. Healthcare:
   • Register with the Medical Services Plan of British Columbia if moving from out of province. Locate healthcare facilities and practitioners in your area and sign up early as some places may have waitlists.
     
7. Connect with the Community:
   • Join local Facebook groups to make connections and get insights about living on the island.
     
8. Outdoor Gear:
   • Prepare for the outdoor lifestyle with appropriate clothing and equipment for activities like hiking, kayaking, and camping. Mountain Warehouse has been our favourite place to shop so far!

FAQs about living on Vancouver Island

Is it expensive to live in Vancouver Island?

Living on Vancouver Island can be a bit pricey, but it really depends on where you choose to call home. Places like Victoria might pinch your wallet more, especially when it comes to finding a place to live.

Everything from your grocery bills to getting around might also cost you a bit more than what you’d expect in other parts of Canada. This is partly because getting goods over to the island adds to the cost.

If you move to one of the smaller towns, you might find things a bit more affordable, though you’ll have fewer shops and restaurants around. The good news is, with all the awesome nature and outdoor activities, you can save a ton on miscellaneous costs each month because there’s so much you can do for free!

What is the cheapest place to live on Vancouver Island?

If you’re looking to stretch your dollars further on Vancouver Island, Port Alberni often tops the charts as one of the more wallet-friendly spots to set up camp. It’s tucked away in a valley, which means it’s a bit off the beaten path but still offers that gorgeous Vancouver Island scenery and a super friendly community vibe.

Housing here tends to be more affordable, whether you’re looking to buy or rent, giving you more bang for your buck.

Does it rain a lot in Vancouver Island?

Yup it sure does! Vancouver Island is pretty famous for its rain, especially in the fall and winter months. That lush, green landscape that the island is known for needs plenty of rain to stay that way.

Places like the west coast of the island, including Tofino and Ucluelet, get a good soaking, making them prime spots for storm watching.

But hey, it’s not all grey skies! The rain brings with it a kind of magical vibe, with misty forests, lakes and cosy days perfect for coffee shop hopping or enjoying a good book. We still get out and about on rainy days, it definitely doesn’t stop us from exploring!

And, the rain doesn’t stick around all year. Spring and summer offer plenty of gorgeous, sunny days that make you forget all about the rainy season.

So, while yes, it does rain a lot, it’s a big part of what makes Vancouver Island such a stunning, vibrant place to live.